“Caleb Lacy brings the story along as the quintessential narrator! [Caleb] too, never fails to deliver. He handles the ‘call backs’ … with aplomb and a rubber face of great expressions! This reviewer completely lost it near the end of the show when Lacy is swept into an emotional song Once In A While...”
— Nancy Durgin, Review of Rocky Horror Show
Rocky Horror Show
City Theater 2022
Photo Credit Rich Obrey
“Caleb Lacy revels in the meaty, over-the-top numbers… singing powerfully, and capturing every element of the caricature down to a perfect accent.”
— Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold BroadwayWorld.com Review of The Producers
“As the sometimes bewildered, always winning Bobby, Caleb Lacy gives an intense performance. He captures the feigned insouciance of the character, the casual charm that endears him to his friends, and the inner vulnerability. Lacy possesses a lovely creamy voice that acquits itself elegantly in Bobby's solos”
— Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold BroadwayWorld.com review of Company
“[Caleb] crafts a spirited show using everything from his toolbox—slapstick and schmaltz, mishaps and mistaken identity, dream sequences, spit takes, [and] over-the-top characters… Lacy guides a competent cast of veterans and first-timers alike in a highly enjoyable production that proves anything can happen in sappy romantic comedy musicals.”
— Reindeer Press, Review of The Drowsy Chaperone